I bought this one: TOYOTA OEM-47750-10090
Which is compatible for:
Starlet V Hatchback (P90) (75 PS, 01.1996 - 10.1999 MY)
Starlet 4 Hatchback (P80) (54 - 75 PS, 12.1989 - 03.1996 MY)
online chat with a supplier suggested I get this one:
TOYOTA OEM -47750-16090
which is compatible for:
Paseo Coupe (EL54) (90 PS, 08.1995 - 06.1999 MY)
Starlet V Hatchback (P90) (75 PS, 01.1996 - 10.1999 MY)
also, this one has mounting bores at 155mm as opposed to the first one which is 130mm. This matches what the mechanic said about the one I bought being too sma