Personally I find it hard to compare they are both very different cars. I know you say running costs arent important but ofcourse they are especially in this climate fuel tax and insurance is only getting more expensive. Starlet will be cheaper on all 3 and with fuel heading well over 1.50 p/l Id have to say the 14mpg from the evo would be enough to put me off. I almost bought an EvoX this year and only avoided it due to the mileage I do. Not just that but the evo is 4wd meaning more tyres, more brakes, more cv joints, more parts to go wrong in all. At the end of the day both cars have their positives and negatives and can both achieve big power and a fast car. As much as you say it doesnt matter the biggest factor is going to be cost and unless you have a money well its what does matter most in the end.